Curtains Match The Windows

Anime & Manga

 * A great deal of the cast of Sailor Moon matches this trope. Of the heroes, Chibiusa, Ami, Michiru, Rei, and Hotaru. And in some artbook pictures, all of them do, including Sailor Moon herself. Of the rest of the cast, all of the Witches Five, several of the Anima-Mates, and Princess Kakyuu.
 * Dijiko (green eyes and hair), Puchiko (brown hair and eyes), and Hikaru (pink hair and eyes) from Di Gi Charat.
 * The Tokyo Mew Mew girls in their Mew Mew forms (and all the time in the manga). Except Berry, 'cause she's special.
 * In the anime Haunted Junction, a large number of characters have hair and eyes the same color, including two out of the three leads.
 * Most of the characters in Yumeiro Pâtissière.
 * The shinigami Watari (golden-blond hair and amber eyes) and the villain Dr. Muraki (silvery-gray eyes and silvery-white hair) in Descendants of Darkness.
 * Black Butler:
 * In the manga, Agni is shown to have white eyes matching his white hair.
 * Madame Red's eyes and hair are...well, red.
 * Ciel's hair is also often shown to be blue, the same color as his eyes though his hair is a much darker shade. In the manga, his hair is a very faded blue/gray, while his eyes are almost navy. In the anime, they're almost exactly the same.
 * Mei-Rin has this as well.

Western Animation

 * Xiaolin Showdown: Jack Spicer has red hair and red eyes.